Please note: This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
It’s Not Just About Getting People Through the Door
If you’re hunting for ways to pack the house with visitors — promotion timelines, circle prospecting, the whole song and dance — hop over to our guide on How to Market and Host a Mega Open House. This one’s about something different: what actually happens once people are standing in the kitchen.
Your seller just spent an entire Sunday pretending their house isn’t covered in their actual life so you could show it off. They want two things in return: a buyer, and the truth about how their home is landing with real people. A genuinely great open house experience delivers both — and, as a nice little bonus, quietly turns every nosy neighbor who’s “just looking” into your next listing appointment.
Setting the Scene
Before a single person walks in, do a lap of the house like you’ve never seen it before. Blinds open, every light on (yes, even at 2pm), thermostat set to “pleasant human being” rather than “we’re trying to save on the electric bill.” Throw on some quiet background music too — a totally silent house has a weird, holding-your-breath energy to it. You want the place to feel like someone actually lives here and loves it, not like a museum exhibit nobody’s allowed to touch.
The Price-Guessing Game
Here’s one of my favorite tricks, and it didn’t actually start at open houses — it started at agent caravans.
I used to go around asking other agents what they thought the best list price would be, and I kept getting the same overly polite, vague non-answers. Nobody wants to be the one who says a real number out loud in front of their peers.
So I flipped the question. Instead of asking for their opinion, I asked them to guess what we were actually going to list it for — reframed as a game instead of an interrogation. Suddenly, people gave real answers. Add a small gift card to the mix, and the honesty shot up even more.
Once I saw how well it worked on agents, I brought the same game to open houses with buyers and neighbors. Set out a fishbowl or a cute little jar, put a sign next to it, and let people drop in their guess along with their contact info. Here’s a sign you can basically copy-paste:
“GUESS THE FINAL SALE PRICE! Closest guess when we close wins a $50 gift card. Write your guess and your contact info below.”
And here’s where the real magic happens: if a listing has been sitting for a few weeks and you already suspect it’s priced too high, this is the gentlest way in the world to get your seller to hear that. It’s not you saying it again. It’s fifteen strangers, independently landing on the same lower number. That’s a much easier pill for a seller to swallow than one more phone call from their agent telling them to cut the price.
When the home closes, don’t just quietly mail the winner their gift card. Post the announcement on your social media (with their okay, obviously) and reach out to them directly to let them know they won. It proves to everyone else who played along that the game was real, and it gives you a perfectly natural, low-pressure reason to reconnect with a lead who toured the home weeks or months earlier.
Quick note: if you’re running this as a more formal drawing with a higher-value prize, it’s worth a quick check of your state’s rules around contests and raffles — a simple guessing game with a modest gift card is generally not an issue, but it’s worth knowing your state’s threshold.
Refreshments & Small Touches
Let’s talk snacks, because I have opinions. Skip the communal bowl of crackers and cheese that everyone side-eyes and nobody wants to be the first to touch. Individual snack bags — a few crackers, a little treat, a bottled water — with your business card taped on are just better in every way: more sanitary, more shareable, and they leave the house WITH the visitor instead of getting abandoned on the counter by 3pm.
Consider asking your favorite lender or a home inspector to split the cost with you. It’s a good deal for everyone: they get to answer mortgage questions on the spot, you get to split the snack budget, and — this is the best part — if they connect with someone you didn’t get a chance to talk to, they’ll usually send that lead right back to you once it’s qualified.
For the Neighbors Checking Out the Competition
Let’s be honest: a solid chunk of your open house traffic isn’t buyers at all. It’s neighbors, quietly snooping to see what a well-marketed listing in their own neighborhood looks like — usually because they’re wondering if now’s the time to sell too. Don’t roll your eyes at them. Treat every single one like the listing appointment they secretly are:
- Real, professionally designed flyers — not something that looks like it came out of a home printer running low on ink
- A simple feature sheet or mini “book” walking through the home’s upgrades and standout details
- A small neighbor-only takeaway, even something tiny with your branding on it
- A sign-up sheet, or better yet a QR code linked to the same digital sign-in tool you’re using for buyers (see our Mega Open House guide for tool recommendations), for anyone who wants to be alerted about future open houses or new listings nearby
Wrapping Up: The Seller Follow-Up
Your seller gave up their entire day for this. The least you can do is not leave them hanging. Within an hour or two of locking up, send them a real update — how many people came through, what the price guesses looked like, anything genuinely useful you picked up along the way. A quick text or call both work; just don’t make them wonder all evening.
And here’s a tiny thing that costs you nothing and means a lot: leave a short handwritten note on the counter before you go. Just a simple thank you for trusting you with their home for the day. It’s the kind of small, human touch that ends up mentioned in five-star reviews months later. For more ways to turn happy sellers into your biggest fans, check out 14 Ideas to Get Your Home Sellers to Rave About Their Experience.
In Summary
At the end of the day, a great open house isn’t about the fanciest flyers or the priciest snacks — it’s about making people feel genuinely welcome, getting your seller real answers instead of polite guesses, and treating every single visitor (buyer, neighbor, or nosy internet stranger) like they might be your next deal. Because honestly? One of them usually is.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I put on a seller feedback form at an open house?
Keep it short: a 1-10 rating on first impression, price expectations (this is where the price-guessing game does double duty), and one open-ended question like “What would make this home a 10 for you?” Long feedback forms get skipped; short ones actually get filled out.
How much should I budget for open house refreshments and prizes?
It doesn’t need to be expensive — individual snack bags typically run $1-3 per person, and a modest gift card ($25-50) is plenty for the price-guessing game. Splitting the cost with a co-sponsoring lender or inspector cuts this further and adds a professional on-site who can answer questions you can’t.
How do I get honest pricing feedback instead of polite small talk?
A structured activity like the price-guessing game gets more honest answers than simply asking someone what they think, since it feels like a game rather than a put-on-the-spot opinion. Anonymous or semi-anonymous comment cards also tend to produce more candid feedback than face-to-face conversation.
Should I let a lender or inspector co-sponsor my open house?
It’s usually a good trade for both sides. A lender can answer mortgage questions on the spot, split the cost of refreshments, and will typically refer back any lead they connect with who didn’t have a chance to talk to you directly — that referral relationship is often worth more than the cost savings alone.
What should I do with neighbors who clearly aren’t buying this home?
Treat them as a future listing opportunity, not a distraction. A polished flyer, a feature one-pager, and a sign-up sheet for future open house alerts turns a curious neighbor into a warm contact for when they eventually decide to sell.
Editor’s note: This article was created by Kerry Lucasse, Agent/Owner at eXp Realty. Information deemed reliable but is subject to change.
Ready to get more from your brokerage? Learn why agents voted eXp Realty Top Place to Work!
Please note: This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
